When I started looking at support for developing world
libraries, I found an article by Curry et al (2002) outlines the conflict of
globalization of libraries. Curry et al(2002) say globalization negatively impacts “developing” countries by shifting
power away from local governments to a handful of corporations and financial
institutions looking for financial gain.
The digital library resources contain mainly information from Western
cultures, in Western languages; and do not reflect local social, environmental
or cultural values. The access to
digital information uses products from “Western” corporations from the internet
to cell service, to the tools to read digitally streamed information. These comments reminds me of the companies
that promoted infant formula as a solution to malnutrition in the 1960’s to
80’s in “third world” countries (Corporate Crime and Violence 1987) rather than
promoting local solutions. The article
by Curry (2002) challenges people to ensure they are partners in developing
world libraries and not “Lady Bountiful”.
It suggests that programs intending to assist libraries in “developing”
countries should focus on traditional areas of need including literacy,
collection development (appropriate for local users) and indigenous book
publishing among others.
On the web I found a non-profit group (Bibliothèques sansfrontières 2014) that promotes library development in the sub-Sahara, India,
and the Caribbean; areas identified as having the lowest digital connectivity (Freakonomics
2014). Then I checked to see if their
programs meet Curry’s (2002) guidelines for assisting library development. I was happy to note that they include all of
the concerns identified in their areas of intervention including: conservation
of cultural heritage, information and culture, and capacity building. The irony of finding this site about world libraries
is that I found out information useful for my students, creating a local impact. Bibliothèques sans frontiers (2014) has
translated a number of the Khan Academy (Khan Academy 2014) math lessons into
French. This is a resource developed in
the “US” to help children learn. I have
heard this is a great resource for students, so finding it in French has been a
bonus that I will be sharing with my colleagues in my School District and the
parents of my students!

The article by Curry, and the idea of assisting in
developing world libraries has a link to our library education at UBC (LLED452;
Vacca et al 2011) where we are encouraged to purchase multicultural literature
to reflect our student population, so all students can see themselves in
literature. I checked out some other
sites and realized there groups that support worldwide literacy whose websites
don’t identify if they consider if the content of the books they are sending is
multicultural (Book Aid International, 2014).
Then I found SCECSAL an African Library Association (SESCAL 2012) that
has conferences to promote literacy and health. One of the posts I read talks about developing
regional school libraries in Zimbabwe. I
realize that these local people should be consulted to figure out how to best help
with improving libraries in Africa.
Next I explored the development of internet access for
access to digital library resources. I
listened to an interesting podcast
which talks about where internet is available in the world, a requirement for
digital world libraries to download resources.
They mention that South Korea is the most wired nation and that rural
areas of inland India, China and the southern Sahara are the least wired
locations in the world. I read another
post that identified that libraries may not need internet, but could work with
cellular service (Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation 2013). In rural Ghana,
a library uses text messaging to provide pregnancy health information to
expectant mothers. This delivery of
“library” information has increased pre-natal visits and cut infant mortality. The delivery of this second service focused on
needs of local people is one of the areas that SCESCAL promotes.
I feel I have barely looked at this complex topic and I
require much more information to really get a good grasp on how to help appropriately
to develop world libraries.
References
Bibliothèques
sans frontières. 2014. Areas of
intervention. Retrieved Feb 20,
2014 from http://www.librarieswithoutborders.org/.
Book Aid. 2014. Book Aid International. http://www.bookaid.org/publisher/the-books-we-need/
Corporate Crime and Violence. 1987.
Infant Formula, hawking disaster in the third world. Retrieved Feb 27, 2014 from http://multinationalmonitor.org/hyper/issues/1987/04/formula.html
Freakonomics. Who
runs the internet a Freakonomics radio podcast.
Retrieved Feb 20, 2014 from http://freakonomics.com/2013/11/14/who-runs-the-internet-a-new-freakonomics-radio-podcast/
Khan Academy avec
Bibliothèques
sans frontières.
2014.
Khan Academy. Retrieved Feb 27,
2014 from http://www.khan-academy.fr/
Vacca R., Vacca, J., and M. Mraz. (2011)
Content Area Reading, Literacy and Learning Across the Curriculum, Tenth
Edition. Pearson Education Inc. Boston, USA
Great post full of excellent examples, strong resources and a french perspective! Thank you for bringing in your critical eye to examine the rationale and impact of these organizations, as well as how they might be able to help you in your own school community!
ReplyDeleteI agree this is a complex topic. You have made some important points about supporting developing countries. There is no simple solution. A great deal of thought needs to go into how to help effectively.
ReplyDeleteI spent a lot of time looking at all the libraries and digital programs that have been implemented in to developing countries as well. Not an easy task. I was somewhat surprised at how many organizations already exist and amazed at how many cell phone users there are in African countries. I like what Peter Gabriel shared in this video (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x9EWDHXy8MY) on his encounter with a woman from Kenya on mobile devices. People in developing countries are well aware of how powerful technology is in transforming their countries and their communities. Not only from an educational perspective but as you also mentioned, from a health perspective as well.
ReplyDelete